TEXAS: What went wrong?

  • TEXAS: What went wrong?

    Posted by Erin Hardick on February 17, 2021 at 5:54 am

    If y’all are like me, you’ve been following this Texas situation very closely. I can’t stop consuming information about what is happening in the Texas power grid/market. 

    Although we don’t have all the facts and likely won’t until this tragic situation is over, I and other members wanted to start a discussion about it.  

    Texas: What analytics could have prevented it? What Analytics should be implemented going forward?

    ——————————
    Erin Hardick
    Senior Research Analyst
    Utility Analytics Institute (UAI)
    CO
    ——————————

    Blake Scherer replied 3 years, 9 months ago 7 Members · 11 Replies
  • 11 Replies
  • Ben Ettlinger

    Member
    February 18, 2021 at 1:35 am

    Thanks for this Matt. So we can say…… Ah Ha….Two out of three are analytics related issues and could have been avoided and can be avoided in the future with better analytics!!:)  Leslie and Kevin looks like we will need more on Forecasting !

     

    ——————————————-
    Original Message:
    Sent: 2/18/2021 12:51:00 PM
    From: Matt Owens
    Subject: RE: TEXAS: What went wrong?

    This utility dive article provides some good insights into the multiple things that went wrong.

    https://www.utilitydive.com/news/power-experts-cite-gas-constraints-as-main-cause-of-ercot-outages-but-syst/595255/?utm_source=Sailthru&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Issue:%202021-02-18%20Utility%20Dive%20Newsletter%20%5Bissue:32530%5D&utm_term=Utility%20Dive

    In summary
    1) More than expected number of gas plants went offline due to a number of factors (gas supply shortage due to cold weather issues at gas storage and pipeline facilities) was the largest contributor to the supply shortage. Article states ~24,000 MW short of expectation out of ~69,000 MW total demand. Getting to the root cause of these issues will require additional investigation but lack of weatherization investment at the plants and supply infrastructure appears to be a key theme.
    2) Higher demand than projected ~10,000 MW higher than forecast
    3) Renewables (wind and solar) – less output than forecast.  Article states ~6,000 MW short of expectation.  Could have been avoided or partially avoided if wind farms had invested in weatherization (like is done in colder climates such as Iowa) but there is a cost to this.

    Other key points
    1) Texas’ ERCOT lacks a capacity market and as a result there may have been an under investment over the past 10 to 20 in additional capacity that could have provided a buffer.  ERCOT’s spinning resever margin is less than in other power grids
    2) Texas grid is an island and is not connected to Western or Eastern power grids.  This means they cannot import power from other locations that may have excess capacity.

    ——————————
    Matt Owens
    Business Development Executive
    West Monroe Partners
    ——————————
    ——————————————-
    Original Message:
    Sent: 02-17-2021 17:54
    From: Erin Hardick
    Subject: TEXAS: What went wrong?

    If y’all are like me, you’ve been following this Texas situation very closely. I can’t stop consuming information about what is happening in the Texas power grid/market.

    Although we don’t have all the facts and likely won’t until this tragic situation is over, I and other members wanted to start a discussion about it.

    Texas: What analytics could have prevented it? What Analytics should be implemented going forward?

    ——————————
    Erin Hardick
    Senior Research Analyst
    Utility Analytics Institute (UAI)
    CO
    ——————————

  • Ben Ettlinger

    Member
    February 18, 2021 at 8:02 am

    It would appear from a thousand miles way that it was a combination of many things, politics, infrastructure, weather prediction, etc. Could it have been predicted? Not sure. Another question to raise is what happened going to affect the march to only renewables? Do fossil fuel peakers still have to be kept in the mix? No sun in a winter storm, frozen wind turbines,  frozen water sources (maybe not in Texas, but potentially elsewhere). Have renewables met their match? The very source of renewables themselves!

    ——————————
    Ben Ettlinger
    Emerging Technologies
    Enterprise Architecture & Engineering Group
    New York Power Authority
    White Plains, NY
    914 681 6496
    ——————————
    ——————————————-
    Original Message:
    Sent: 02-17-2021 17:54
    From: Erin Hardick
    Subject: TEXAS: What went wrong?

    If y’all are like me, you’ve been following this Texas situation very closely. I can’t stop consuming information about what is happening in the Texas power grid/market.

    Although we don’t have all the facts and likely won’t until this tragic situation is over, I and other members wanted to start a discussion about it.

    Texas: What analytics could have prevented it? What Analytics should be implemented going forward?

    ——————————
    Erin Hardick
    Senior Research Analyst
    Utility Analytics Institute (UAI)
    CO
    ——————————

  • Glen Jessup

    Member
    February 18, 2021 at 8:13 am

    There was an interesting article in Economist magazine yesterday that summarized many of the contributing factors (sorry, you may need to sign up to view; I’m a subscriber):

    The freeze in Texas exposes America’s infrastructural failings

    The Economist remove preview
    The freeze in Texas exposes America’s infrastructural failings
    WHEN IT RAINS, it pours, and when it snows, the lights turn off. Or so it goes in Texas. After a winter storm pummelled the Lone Star State with record snowfall and the lowest temperatures in more than 30 years, millions were left without electricity and heat.
    View this on The Economist >

    ——————————
    Glen Jessup BA, CDMP
    Specialist – Asset Management
    ENBRIDGE

    Original Message:
    Sent: 02-18-2021 08:02
    From: Ben Ettlinger
    Subject: TEXAS: What went wrong?

    It would appear from a thousand miles way that it was a combination of many things, politics, infrastructure, weather prediction, etc. Could it have been predicted? Not sure. Another question to raise is what happened going to affect the march to only renewables? Do fossil fuel peakers still have to be kept in the mix? No sun in a winter storm, frozen wind turbines,  frozen water sources (maybe not in Texas, but potentially elsewhere). Have renewables met their match? The very source of renewables themselves!

    ——————————
    Ben Ettlinger
    Emerging Technologies
    Enterprise Architecture & Engineering Group
    New York Power Authority
    White Plains, NY
    914 681 6496
    ——————————

    Original Message:
    Sent: 02-17-2021 17:54
    From: Erin Hardick
    Subject: TEXAS: What went wrong?

    If y’all are like me, you’ve been following this Texas situation very closely. I can’t stop consuming information about what is happening in the Texas power grid/market.

    Although we don’t have all the facts and likely won’t until this tragic situation is over, I and other members wanted to start a discussion about it.

    Texas: What analytics could have prevented it? What Analytics should be implemented going forward?

    ——————————
    Erin Hardick
    Senior Research Analyst
    Utility Analytics Institute (UAI)
    CO
    ——————————

  • Erin Hardick

    Member
    February 18, 2021 at 12:18 pm

    From what I’ve read and looking through the ERCOT data, a few things went wrong:

    • ERCOT under forecasted demand and therefore did not have enough generators ready to meet demand. A common question I’ve seen around this issue is whether or not ERCOT’s historical weather data was helpful in predicting conditions. In 2011 Texas saw a similar situation with a severe winter storm that caused major outages, however it didn’t last as long as this current storm and didn’t affect a large potion of the state. Also, the “extreme scenarios” ERCOT planned for were far more conservative than what actually happened. (i.e. extreme generator outage scenario (for thermal generators) planned was 14 GW. 30-40 GW ended up going offline). 
      • Could better data analytics help create a more accurate forecast of demand?  
    • Lack of investment in “winterizing” infrastructure caused the major of nat gas generators to go offline. Because of the the ERCOT market structure, plant operators have delayed infrastructure investments to protect against cold weather, which resulted in 30-40GW of fossil power plants to go offline. 
      • Could asset analytics play a role in predicting performance in severe weather conditions, particularly winter storms that Texas has never seen before? 
    • Texas’ independent grid prevented the state from receiving help. Since ERCOT is not regulated by FERC, it cannot connect with the western/eastern interconnect preventing them from bringing in electricity from other states.
      • Could data/analytics be used to show how connecting with the rest of the US grid would increase reliability? 
    • Texas homes are not built to retain heat, driving demand through the roof. An excerpt from an article by Josh Rhodes, Ph.D. Research Associate at The University of Texas at Austin, says, “Temperatures are forecasted to get down to 10F in Austin, so the indoor/outdoor difference between a “comfortable” indoor temperature of 70F is 60F (70F-10F),  double what we are trying to control in the summer. Keep in mind our homes are designed with insulation for a 30F differential and a preference for shedding heat, not a 60F differential with a desire to retain heat.” 
      • Could data about customer homes be used to better forecast demand? 

    This is not an extensive list, but I thought these were some of the areas that could benefit from better data quality and analytics. 

    Thoughts?

    ——————————
    Erin Hardick
    Senior Research Analyst
    Utility Analytics Institute (UAI)
    CO
    ——————————
    ——————————————-
    Original Message:
    Sent: 02-18-2021 08:13
    From: Glen Jessup
    Subject: TEXAS: What went wrong?

    There was an interesting article in Economist magazine yesterday that summarized many of the contributing factors (sorry, you may need to sign up to view; I’m a subscriber):

    The freeze in Texas exposes America’s infrastructural failings

    The Economist remove preview
    The freeze in Texas exposes America’s infrastructural failings
    WHEN IT RAINS, it pours, and when it snows, the lights turn off. Or so it goes in Texas. After a winter storm pummelled the Lone Star State with record snowfall and the lowest temperatures in more than 30 years, millions were left without electricity and heat.
    View this on The Economist >

    ——————————
    Glen Jessup BA, CDMP
    Specialist – Asset Management
    ENBRIDGE

    Original Message:
    Sent: 02-18-2021 08:02
    From: Ben Ettlinger
    Subject: TEXAS: What went wrong?

    It would appear from a thousand miles way that it was a combination of many things, politics, infrastructure, weather prediction, etc. Could it have been predicted? Not sure. Another question to raise is what happened going to affect the march to only renewables? Do fossil fuel peakers still have to be kept in the mix? No sun in a winter storm, frozen wind turbines,  frozen water sources (maybe not in Texas, but potentially elsewhere). Have renewables met their match? The very source of renewables themselves!

    ——————————
    Ben Ettlinger
    Emerging Technologies
    Enterprise Architecture & Engineering Group
    New York Power Authority
    White Plains, NY
    914 681 6496

    Original Message:
    Sent: 02-17-2021 17:54
    From: Erin Hardick
    Subject: TEXAS: What went wrong?

    If y’all are like me, you’ve been following this Texas situation very closely. I can’t stop consuming information about what is happening in the Texas power grid/market.

    Although we don’t have all the facts and likely won’t until this tragic situation is over, I and other members wanted to start a discussion about it.

    Texas: What analytics could have prevented it? What Analytics should be implemented going forward?

    ——————————
    Erin Hardick
    Senior Research Analyst
    Utility Analytics Institute (UAI)
    CO
    ——————————

  • Erin Hardick

    Member
    February 18, 2021 at 12:27 pm

    Other good reads:

    A Plan to Future-Proof the Texas Power Grid
    Texas largely relies on natural gas for power. It wasn’t ready for the extreme cold.
    What’s behind the Texas power outages?

    ——————————
    Erin Hardick
    Senior Research Analyst
    Utility Analytics Institute (UAI)
    CO
    ——————————
    ——————————————-
    Original Message:
    Sent: 02-18-2021 12:17
    From: Erin Hardick
    Subject: TEXAS: What went wrong?

    From what I’ve read and looking through the ERCOT data, a few things went wrong:

    • ERCOT under forecasted demand and therefore did not have enough generators ready to meet demand. A common question I’ve seen around this issue is whether or not ERCOT’s historical weather data was helpful in predicting conditions. In 2011 Texas saw a similar situation with a severe winter storm that caused major outages, however it didn’t last as long as this current storm and didn’t affect a large potion of the state. Also, the “extreme scenarios” ERCOT planned for were far more conservative than what actually happened. (i.e. extreme generator outage scenario (for thermal generators) planned was 14 GW. 30-40 GW ended up going offline). 
      • Could better data analytics help create a more accurate forecast of demand?  
    • Lack of investment in “winterizing” infrastructure caused the major of nat gas generators to go offline. Because of the the ERCOT market structure, plant operators have delayed infrastructure investments to protect against cold weather, which resulted in 30-40GW of fossil power plants to go offline. 
      • Could asset analytics play a role in predicting performance in severe weather conditions, particularly winter storms that Texas has never seen before? 
    • Texas’ independent grid prevented the state from receiving help. Since ERCOT is not regulated by FERC, it cannot connect with the western/eastern interconnect preventing them from bringing in electricity from other states.
      • Could data/analytics be used to show how connecting with the rest of the US grid would increase reliability? 
    • Texas homes are not built to retain heat, driving demand through the roof. An excerpt from an article by Josh Rhodes, Ph.D. Research Associate at The University of Texas at Austin, says, “Temperatures are forecasted to get down to 10F in Austin, so the indoor/outdoor difference between a “comfortable” indoor temperature of 70F is 60F (70F-10F),  double what we are trying to control in the summer. Keep in mind our homes are designed with insulation for a 30F differential and a preference for shedding heat, not a 60F differential with a desire to retain heat.” 
      • Could data about customer homes be used to better forecast demand? 

    This is not an extensive list, but I thought these were some of the areas that could benefit from better data quality and analytics.

    Thoughts?

    ——————————
    Erin Hardick
    Senior Research Analyst
    Utility Analytics Institute (UAI)
    CO
    ——————————

    Original Message:
    Sent: 02-18-2021 08:13
    From: Glen Jessup
    Subject: TEXAS: What went wrong?

    There was an interesting article in Economist magazine yesterday that summarized many of the contributing factors (sorry, you may need to sign up to view; I’m a subscriber):

    The freeze in Texas exposes America’s infrastructural failings

    The Economist remove preview
    The freeze in Texas exposes America’s infrastructural failings
    WHEN IT RAINS, it pours, and when it snows, the lights turn off. Or so it goes in Texas. After a winter storm pummelled the Lone Star State with record snowfall and the lowest temperatures in more than 30 years, millions were left without electricity and heat.
    View this on The Economist >

    ——————————
    Glen Jessup BA, CDMP
    Specialist – Asset Management
    ENBRIDGE

    Original Message:
    Sent: 02-18-2021 08:02
    From: Ben Ettlinger
    Subject: TEXAS: What went wrong?

    It would appear from a thousand miles way that it was a combination of many things, politics, infrastructure, weather prediction, etc. Could it have been predicted? Not sure. Another question to raise is what happened going to affect the march to only renewables? Do fossil fuel peakers still have to be kept in the mix? No sun in a winter storm, frozen wind turbines,  frozen water sources (maybe not in Texas, but potentially elsewhere). Have renewables met their match? The very source of renewables themselves!

    ——————————
    Ben Ettlinger
    Emerging Technologies
    Enterprise Architecture & Engineering Group
    New York Power Authority
    White Plains, NY
    914 681 6496

    Original Message:
    Sent: 02-17-2021 17:54
    From: Erin Hardick
    Subject: TEXAS: What went wrong?

    If y’all are like me, you’ve been following this Texas situation very closely. I can’t stop consuming information about what is happening in the Texas power grid/market.

    Although we don’t have all the facts and likely won’t until this tragic situation is over, I and other members wanted to start a discussion about it.

    Texas: What analytics could have prevented it? What Analytics should be implemented going forward?

    ——————————
    Erin Hardick
    Senior Research Analyst
    Utility Analytics Institute (UAI)
    CO
    ——————————

  • Matt Owens

    Member
    February 18, 2021 at 12:51 pm

    This utility dive article provides some good insights into the multiple things that went wrong.

    https://www.utilitydive.com/news/power-experts-cite-gas-constraints-as-main-cause-of-ercot-outages-but-syst/595255/?utm_source=Sailthru&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Issue:%202021-02-18%20Utility%20Dive%20Newsletter%20%5Bissue:32530%5D&utm_term=Utility%20Dive

    In summary
    1) More than expected number of gas plants went offline due to a number of factors (gas supply shortage due to cold weather issues at gas storage and pipeline facilities) was the largest contributor to the supply shortage. Article states ~24,000 MW short of expectation out of ~69,000 MW total demand. Getting to the root cause of these issues will require additional investigation but lack of weatherization investment at the plants and supply infrastructure appears to be a key theme.
    2) Higher demand than projected ~10,000 MW higher than forecast
    3) Renewables (wind and solar) – less output than forecast.  Article states ~6,000 MW short of expectation.  Could have been avoided or partially avoided if wind farms had invested in weatherization (like is done in colder climates such as Iowa) but there is a cost to this.

    Other key points
    1) Texas’ ERCOT lacks a capacity market and as a result there may have been an under investment over the past 10 to 20 in additional capacity that could have provided a buffer.  ERCOT’s spinning resever margin is less than in other power grids
    2) Texas grid is an island and is not connected to Western or Eastern power grids.  This means they cannot import power from other locations that may have excess capacity.

    ——————————
    Matt Owens
    Business Development Executive
    West Monroe Partners
    ——————————
    ——————————————-
    Original Message:
    Sent: 02-17-2021 17:54
    From: Erin Hardick
    Subject: TEXAS: What went wrong?

    If y’all are like me, you’ve been following this Texas situation very closely. I can’t stop consuming information about what is happening in the Texas power grid/market.

    Although we don’t have all the facts and likely won’t until this tragic situation is over, I and other members wanted to start a discussion about it.

    Texas: What analytics could have prevented it? What Analytics should be implemented going forward?

    ——————————
    Erin Hardick
    Senior Research Analyst
    Utility Analytics Institute (UAI)
    CO
    ——————————

  • Ben Ettlinger

    Member
    February 19, 2021 at 2:01 am

    Sorry I didn’t see this earlier. Maybe we need a page on the web site for links to things like this.

     

    Ben Ettlinger

    IT Data Analytics Architect

    123 Main St.

    White Plains, NY 10601

    914-681-6496 | Ben.Ettlinger@nypa.gov

    http://www.nypa.gov

     

    ——————————————-
    Original Message:
    Sent: 2/19/2021 12:14:00 PM
    From: Blake Scherer
    Subject: RE: TEXAS: What went wrong?

    IEEE Smart Grid is having a panel session today,
    Panel on The Texas Electric Power Crisis – IEEE Smart Grid

    ——————————
    Blake Scherer
    Senior Engineer II
    Benton PUD
    Kennewick WA
    509-585-5361
    ——————————
    ——————————————-
    Original Message:
    Sent: 02-17-2021 17:54
    From: Erin Hardick
    Subject: TEXAS: What went wrong?

    If y’all are like me, you’ve been following this Texas situation very closely. I can’t stop consuming information about what is happening in the Texas power grid/market.

    Although we don’t have all the facts and likely won’t until this tragic situation is over, I and other members wanted to start a discussion about it.

    Texas: What analytics could have prevented it? What Analytics should be implemented going forward?

    ——————————
    Erin Hardick
    Senior Research Analyst
    Utility Analytics Institute (UAI)
    CO
    ——————————

  • Sandi Joralemon

    Member
    February 19, 2021 at 7:28 am

    I didn’t see it either. Is it possible to get a link to the recording?

    Thanks.

     

    New Braunfels Utilities NBU Facebook Page NBU on Twitter NBU LinkedIn Page NBU YouTube Channel

    Sandi Joralemon, PMP
    Data Strategist
    355 FM 306 |
    New Braunfels, Texas 78130
    sjoralemon@nbutexas.com | 830.608.8941

    ——————————————-
    Original Message:
    Sent: 2/19/2021 2:01:00 PM
    From: Ben Ettlinger
    Subject: RE: TEXAS: What went wrong?

    Sorry I didn’t see this earlier. Maybe we need a page on the web site for links to things like this.

     

    Ben Ettlinger

    IT Data Analytics Architect

    123 Main St.

    White Plains, NY 10601

    914-681-6496 | Ben.Ettlinger@nypa.gov

    http://www.nypa.gov

     

    ——————————————-
    Original Message:
    Sent: 2/19/2021 12:14:00 PM
    From: Blake Scherer
    Subject: RE: TEXAS: What went wrong?

    IEEE Smart Grid is having a panel session today,
    Panel on The Texas Electric Power Crisis – IEEE Smart Grid

    ——————————
    Blake Scherer
    Senior Engineer II
    Benton PUD
    Kennewick WA
    509-585-5361
    ——————————
    ——————————————-
    Original Message:
    Sent: 02-17-2021 17:54
    From: Erin Hardick
    Subject: TEXAS: What went wrong?

    If y’all are like me, you’ve been following this Texas situation very closely. I can’t stop consuming information about what is happening in the Texas power grid/market.

    Although we don’t have all the facts and likely won’t until this tragic situation is over, I and other members wanted to start a discussion about it.

    Texas: What analytics could have prevented it? What Analytics should be implemented going forward?

    ——————————
    Erin Hardick
    Senior Research Analyst
    Utility Analytics Institute (UAI)
    CO
    ——————————

  • Leslie Cook (Adm)

    Member
    February 19, 2021 at 8:05 am

    Hello @Ben and @Sandi,

    Happy Friday! I hope you are well. I see that you both stated that you did not ​see the link that Blake Scherer shared earlier today for the IEEE Panel on the Texas Electric Power Crisis. I want to make sure you have your “Community Notifications” for Ask Your Network set-up to receive messages in REAL TIME. If you are set-up to receive REAL TIME messages for the discussion on Ask Your Network, you will receive messages posted in Ask Your Network in your inbox immediately upon them being posted. This is the fastest and most visible way to get messages and resources shared by your fellow members and from UAI directly into your email inbox to ensure you don’t miss something important and are able to review items in a timely manner. 

    Please find directions below on how to change this feature if you don’t have your “Community Notifications” set to REAL TIME for Ask Your Network.

    I also see that you asked if we could get the link to the recording of this panel. I did not register for it, so I do not have the link to the recording. Perhaps another member of UAI can help you or reach out directly to IEEE. 

    If you have questions about the below directions or would like a demo on how to change any Community Notification, Email Preferences, or any else on UAI Connect, please reach out to me at lcook@utilityanalytics.com. Thanks so much! 

    How-to change your “Community Notifications” to REAL TIME for Ask Your Network:

    1. Go to your profile on UAI Connect at https://connect.utilityanalytics.com/directory/profile

    2. ​Once on your profile, click on “MY ACCOUNT”, and then scroll down to “Community Notifications” and click it. Screen shot included below for reference.

    Screen Shot of MY ACCOUNT to provide directions on changing

    3. Once on the “Community Notifications” page, scroll down to the section called “NOTIFICATION SETTINGS”. Screen shot included below for reference.

    4. Continue scrolling until you find Ask Your Network in the list. Click on the menu to the right of Ask Your Network, and then scroll down to select REAL TIME. Screen shot included below for your reference.

    You should be set after clicking on REAL TIME. However, sometimes this function is a little quirky, so I often click out of my profile to another page, like the “Events” page, and then go back to my profile and repeat the steps above to make sure the selection saved. This is a safeguard to ensure it accepted your changes. 

    You are now set to receive messages posted in Ask Your Network in REAL TIME! 

    Cheers!

         Leslie

    ——————————
    Leslie Cook
    Membership & Digital Engagement Manager
    Utility Analytics Institute (UAI)
    719-203-8650, lcook@utilityanalytics.com
    ——————————
    ——————————————-
    Original Message:
    Sent: 02-19-2021 19:27
    From: Sandi Joralemon
    Subject: TEXAS: What went wrong?

    I didn’t see it either. Is it possible to get a link to the recording?

    Thanks.

     

    New Braunfels Utilities NBU Facebook Page NBU on Twitter NBU LinkedIn Page NBU YouTube Channel

    Sandi Joralemon, PMP
    Data Strategist
    355 FM 306 |
    New Braunfels, Texas 78130
    sjoralemon@nbutexas.com | 830.608.8941

    Original Message:
    Sent: 2/19/2021 2:01:00 PM
    From: Ben Ettlinger
    Subject: RE: TEXAS: What went wrong?

    Sorry I didn’t see this earlier. Maybe we need a page on the web site for links to things like this.

     

    Ben Ettlinger

    IT Data Analytics Architect

    123 Main St.

    White Plains, NY 10601

    914-681-6496 | Ben.Ettlinger@nypa.gov

    http://www.nypa.gov

     

    Original Message:
    Sent: 2/19/2021 12:14:00 PM
    From: Blake Scherer
    Subject: RE: TEXAS: What went wrong?

    IEEE Smart Grid is having a panel session today,
    Panel on The Texas Electric Power Crisis – IEEE Smart Grid

    ——————————
    Blake Scherer
    Senior Engineer II
    Benton PUD
    Kennewick WA
    509-585-5361
    ——————————

    Original Message:
    Sent: 02-17-2021 17:54
    From: Erin Hardick
    Subject: TEXAS: What went wrong?

    If y’all are like me, you’ve been following this Texas situation very closely. I can’t stop consuming information about what is happening in the Texas power grid/market.

    Although we don’t have all the facts and likely won’t until this tragic situation is over, I and other members wanted to start a discussion about it.

    Texas: What analytics could have prevented it? What Analytics should be implemented going forward?

    ——————————
    Erin Hardick
    Senior Research Analyst
    Utility Analytics Institute (UAI)
    CO
    ——————————

  • Blake Scherer

    Member
    February 19, 2021 at 12:14 pm

    IEEE Smart Grid is having a panel session today,
    Panel on The Texas Electric Power Crisis – IEEE Smart Grid

    ——————————
    Blake Scherer
    Senior Engineer II
    Benton PUD
    Kennewick WA
    509-585-5361
    ——————————
    ——————————————-
    Original Message:
    Sent: 02-17-2021 17:54
    From: Erin Hardick
    Subject: TEXAS: What went wrong?

    If y’all are like me, you’ve been following this Texas situation very closely. I can’t stop consuming information about what is happening in the Texas power grid/market.

    Although we don’t have all the facts and likely won’t until this tragic situation is over, I and other members wanted to start a discussion about it.

    Texas: What analytics could have prevented it? What Analytics should be implemented going forward?

    ——————————
    Erin Hardick
    Senior Research Analyst
    Utility Analytics Institute (UAI)
    CO
    ——————————

  • Blake Scherer

    Member
    February 22, 2021 at 11:35 am

    Here is the link to the webinar recording,
    https://resourcecenter.smartgrid.ieee.org/education/webinar-videos/SGWEB0153.html

    You may need an IEEE login to access.

    ——————————
    Blake Scherer
    Senior Engineer II
    Benton PUD
    Kennewick WA
    ——————————
    ——————————————-
    Original Message:
    Sent: 02-19-2021 19:27
    From: Sandi Joralemon
    Subject: TEXAS: What went wrong?

    I didn’t see it either. Is it possible to get a link to the recording?

    Thanks.

     

    New Braunfels Utilities NBU Facebook Page NBU on Twitter NBU LinkedIn Page NBU YouTube Channel

    Sandi Joralemon, PMP
    Data Strategist
    355 FM 306 |
    New Braunfels, Texas 78130
    sjoralemon@nbutexas.com | 830.608.8941

    Original Message:
    Sent: 2/19/2021 2:01:00 PM
    From: Ben Ettlinger
    Subject: RE: TEXAS: What went wrong?

    Sorry I didn’t see this earlier. Maybe we need a page on the web site for links to things like this.

     

    Ben Ettlinger

    IT Data Analytics Architect

    123 Main St.

    White Plains, NY 10601

    914-681-6496 | Ben.Ettlinger@nypa.gov

    http://www.nypa.gov

     

    Original Message:
    Sent: 2/19/2021 12:14:00 PM
    From: Blake Scherer
    Subject: RE: TEXAS: What went wrong?

    IEEE Smart Grid is having a panel session today,
    Panel on The Texas Electric Power Crisis – IEEE Smart Grid

    ——————————
    Blake Scherer
    Senior Engineer II
    Benton PUD
    Kennewick WA
    509-585-5361
    ——————————

    Original Message:
    Sent: 02-17-2021 17:54
    From: Erin Hardick
    Subject: TEXAS: What went wrong?

    If y’all are like me, you’ve been following this Texas situation very closely. I can’t stop consuming information about what is happening in the Texas power grid/market.

    Although we don’t have all the facts and likely won’t until this tragic situation is over, I and other members wanted to start a discussion about it.

    Texas: What analytics could have prevented it? What Analytics should be implemented going forward?

    ——————————
    Erin Hardick
    Senior Research Analyst
    Utility Analytics Institute (UAI)
    CO
    ——————————

Log in to reply.